RevenueBase Blog

How to Structure a Proof-of-Concept (POC) for Evaluating a Data Provider

If you’re evaluating a new data provider, one of the most important steps is running a proper proof of concept (POC). I’ve done hundreds of these over the years, and the companies that get the most value out of them tend to follow a simple structure that answers two key questions:

  1. Do you have the coverage I need?
  2. Do you have enough of the right companies and contacts I need?
  3. Can I trust the accuracy and freshness of the data?

If you’re reading this, you probably already know how painful it is to buy data that looks good on a slide but falls apart when your team actually uses it. Whether you’re building an ABM platform, enriching customer records, or powering a sales motion, here’s how I recommend running a high-signal POC that tells you what you really need to know.

Step 1: Test for Match Rates Using LinkedIn URLs

The single most reliable identifier for B2B contact data is a LinkedIn profile URL. It never changes and is incredibly specific.

What to do:

  • Send 100–200 exact LinkedIn profile URLs.

What you get:

  • A report showing match rates.
  • Subset of enriched fields like name, title, company, email address, phone, and more (RevenueBase supports 150+ fields).
  • Confidence that the provider has your exact targets in their dataset.

? Pro tip: Ask the vendor for record refresh dates or “last updated” dates for transparency and to help build confidence in the data.

Step 2: Test Domain + Persona Coverage

If you don’t have LinkedIn URLs, the next best test is to check how well the provider covers your ICP based on company domains and persona-level filters.

What to do:

  • Send a list of domains
  • Include 1–3 job title keywords/personas you care about for each account (e.g., “VP HR,” “Head of Engineering”).

What you get:

  • A report showing how many valid contacts the provider can find at each account.
  • Optional enrichment data appended per contact (email, phone, title, LinkedIn URL, etc.)/ Subset data sample.

? This test helps you understand how much value you can deliver to your customers if you’re reselling or embedding the data.

Step 3: Define Success Criteria Upfront

Before you run the POC, be clear on what “good” looks like. This makes evaluation easier and avoids internal confusion.

Here are a few criteria I typically ask customers to define:

  • Match rate to ensure you can update your existing records (e.g., 80%+ match on LinkedIn URL list)
  • Email accuracy (e.g., <5% bounce rate in your downstream system)
  • Unique profiles (e.g., can you surface companies and/or people in ways you can’t with your status quo?)
  • Data freshness (e.g., last verified within 60 days)
  • Compliance (e.g., how and where is this data be collected)

Step 4: Don’t Just Test ? Validate

This is where a lot of POCs fall flat. They focus on coverage but skip accuracy and freshness. Make sure someone on your team actually uses the test data in your environment- whether that’s a CRM, a product workflow, or an outbound campaign.

? At RevenueBase, we encourage customers to manually spot-check results (not via Zerbounce, Neverounce since those tools cannot validate catchall domains). Did the email go through? Did the title match what’s on LinkedIn? Did we return someone who actually works there?

Bonus: Ask for a Data Dictionary and Coverage Map

You’d be surprised how many providers won’t tell you what’s actually in their dataset. That’s a red flag. We share our full data dictionary and global coverage breakdown before we even run the POC, so you know exactly what you’re getting into.

Wrapping It Up

A well-run POC can save you months of frustration and help you avoid expensive mistakes. It’s also the best way to separate providers who just repackage the same stale lists from those who actually generate and maintain their own data.

If you’re running enrichment for your platform, product, or pipeline and want to test Revenue base- let’s do it right. I’ll personally help you set up a POC that proves what matters most: quality, coverage, and confidence.

Want to run a POC? Contact us here.

CATEGORIES