Company lists · Data refreshed November 2026

Top 25 Reciprocal insurers based in the United States

RevenueBase identified 206 company matches for reciprocal insurers associated with the United States as of November 2026 and tracks 21,733 professional contacts across them, including 9,216 with verified work emails. Raleigh is the largest hub.

This list covers company matches for reciprocal insurers associated with the United States, found by RevenueBase SmartSearch using the meaning of business descriptions in its company graph at Exact. Ranked by professionals tracked, largest first. Rows show recorded descriptions where available, Exact search membership and the snapshot date. Data refreshed November 6, 2026.

Published by RevenueBase, a B2B data infrastructure company. This list was built with RevenueBase SmartSearch, the natural-language company search RevenueBase customers use to build their own targeted lists and unlock verified emails and direct dials at the companies on them. How these lists are built and judged.

How to read this list RevenueBase SmartSearch · Exact Recorded Nov 6, 2026 How this list was built
206Companies
21,733Contacts tracked
9,216Verified emails
Explore this list → Free signup · no credit card · 500 free credits

The 25 largest reciprocal insurers based in the United States

Ranked by team size
Top 25 of 206 company matches for reciprocal insurers based in the United States, ordered by professional contacts tracked in RevenueBase, largest first. Recorded Nov 6, 2026. The RevenueBase SmartSearch column shows Exact match membership in this saved search. Click a contact count to view that company's people. Totals use company locations recorded by RevenueBase; the displayed preview is a smaller selection.
#CompanyRevenueBase SmartSearchHeadquartersEmployeesContacts
1Exact matchColumbia, MO, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 20261,001-5,0004,016 contacts →

Exact match

“Shelter Insurance® is a property casualty insurance company offering auto and home insurance in addition to several other insurance products, including: Life Insurance Renters…”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
2Exact matchLincoln, RI, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 20261,001-5,0003,181 contacts →

Exact match

“When you look at Amica, you’ll see we’re different.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
3Exact matchCincinnati, OH, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 20261,001-5,0001,176 contacts →

Exact match

“American Modern provides insurance solutions for customers who need coverage not readily found in the general market.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
4Exact matchSarasota, FL, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026501-1,0001,069 contacts →

Exact match

“FCCI Insurance Group provides commercial property and casualty insurance.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
5Exact matchColumbus, IL, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 20261,001-5,000867 contacts →

Exact match

“Encova Insurance provides commercial, auto and home insurance.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
6Exact matchEdina, MN, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026501-1,000863 contacts →

Exact match

“Celebrating 125 years of service, Western National Insurance is a super-regional group of property-and-casualty insurance companies providing personal and commercial coverage in…”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
7Exact matchGrinnell, IA, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026501-1,000687 contacts →

Exact match

“Now in our second century of service, still committed to our trusted relationships with you.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
8Exact matchMonterey, CA, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026201-500579 contacts →

Exact match

“Established in 1898, Capital Insurance Group® (CIG) is a leading regional property and casualty insurer in the Western U.S.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
9Exact matchNew York, CT, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026201-500377 contacts →

Exact match

“Greater New York Insurance Companies are leading providers of middle market property and casualty insurance focusing on commercial real estate, including condominiums, co-op…”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
10Exact matchBala Cynwyd, PA, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026201-500313 contacts →

Exact match

“GBLI | Global Indemnity provides specialty property and casualty coverage for a wide range of markets-from small business, manufactured homes, and vacant property to agriculture…”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
11Exact matchBloomington, MN, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026201-500285 contacts →

Exact match

“SFM is a mutually owned workers’ compensation insurance company headquartered in Bloomington, Minn.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
12Exact matchDedham, VA, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-200279 contacts →

Exact match

“Norfolk & Dedham Insurance has been protecting homes, autos, and businesses since 1825.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
13Exact matchMinneapolis, MN, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026201-500274 contacts →

Exact match

“Berkley Risk provides at-risk and alternative risk insurance program management services to a broad range of groups and individuals including captives, pools, associations, RRGs…”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
14Exact matchMontpelier, VT, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026201-500273 contacts →

Exact match

“Chartered in 1828, the Vermont Mutual Insurance Company is one of the 10 oldest mutual property/casualty insurers in the United States.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
15Exact matchPrinceton, NJ, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026201-500236 contacts →

Exact match

“At CURE, we don’t need reform to do what’s right.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
16Exact matchMcpherson, KS, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 2026201-500233 contacts →

Exact match

“Farmers Alliance began in in the small, rural community of McPherson, Kansas.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
17Exact matchRichmond, VA, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 20261,001-5,000229 contacts →

Exact match

Recorded description not available.

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
18Exact matchWashington, DC, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-200172 contacts →

Exact match

“The American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA) is the primary national trade association for home, auto, and business insurers.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
19Exact matchNew Holland, PA, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-200160 contacts →

Exact match

“Goodville Mutual was founded in 1926 by a small group of Mennonite aware of the growing need for automobile insurance in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
20Exact matchIndianapolis, DC, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-200131 contacts →

Exact match

“The National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies consists of more than 1,300 member companies, including six of the top 10 property/casualty insurers in the United States.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
21Exact matchBurlington, MA, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-200126 contacts →

Exact match

“A.I.M.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
22Exact matchCary, NC, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-200104 contacts →

Exact match

Recorded description not available.

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
23Exact matchOverland Park, KS, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-200103 contacts →

Exact match

Recorded description not available.

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
24Exact matchMontpelier, NY, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-20088 contacts →

Exact match

“Located in the Green Mountains of central Vermont and first established in 1874, Union Mutual has been providing quality insurance products for over 140 years.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase
25Exact matchPhiladelphia, PA, United StatesHQ recorded Nov 6, 202651-20083 contacts →

Exact match

“The PCRB is a non-profit corporation formed in 1915 in accordance with the insurance laws of Pennsylvania and is not affiliated with state government.”

Recorded in the RevenueBase company graph · Nov 6, 2026 · View company records in RevenueBase

Showing 25 of 206 reciprocal insurers based in the United States

See the full list, filter by size, metro and specialty, and access 9,216 tracked professional contacts with verified work emails. Direct dials are available where recorded.

Free signup · no credit card

View the full list →

Reciprocal insurers based in the United States at a glance

As of Nov 6, 2026
42.4%Verified-email coverage
105.5Average contacts per company
11-50Median size (employees)
1.9%Largest-city concentration · Raleigh
Nov 6, 2026Page data refreshed

Companies by employee count

1-10
76
11-50
70
51-200
36
201-500
11
501-1,000
4
1,001-5,000
7

Email recency for this list is measured worldwide rather than for United States, so it is reported there. Company counts and contact totals on this page are exact for United States, over 206 companies.

How this list was built

The recorded descriptions help you assess these company matches. Check a company’s website for its current services and locations.

Source
The RevenueBase company graph: 60 million companies and 398.9 million professional contacts resolved from primary sources, queried with RevenueBase SmartSearch, the natural-language company search available to every RevenueBase user.
What qualifies
Company records associated with the United States whose business descriptions match “reciprocal insurers” by meaning at the Exact setting. Descriptions are compiled in the RevenueBase company graph from public websites, profiles and company information where available; they are not guaranteed quotations from the company's website.
RevenueBase SmartSearch
Describe a niche company in your own words to find businesses by meaning. Exact, Similar, Related and Broad control the breadth of RevenueBase SmartSearch. This saved list uses Exact. Each row's Exact match badge shows inclusion in that search, not an individual score or a service-quality judgment.
Public preview
The public preview omits records without a verified work email. Where headquarters information is recorded, preview rows are also filtered to this page’s location. Dataset totals and geographic summaries describe the full matched records before these preview filters.
Match quality
RevenueBase's August 25, 2026 study assessed 4,198 description/company pairs across matching settings. The publisher reports 86% good or better at Exact. This evaluates the method across queries; it does not audit this individual list. Recorded company descriptions, where available, help you judge each match yourself. Read the full methodology: how the lists are built and what the study measures.
Ranking
Team size, largest first: companies are ordered by the number of professionals RevenueBase tracks at each one. Employee ranges shown are reported bands, for context.
Verification
Every displayed company carries at least one verified work email. RevenueBase tracks 9,216 professional contacts with verified work emails across the full matched dataset. Contacts re-verify on a rolling cadence, and each contact's own verification date is shown inside RevenueBase.
Refresh
This page's figures were pulled from the company graph on November 6, 2026. Lists refresh periodically as the graph is re-checked.
Record context
Company records and descriptions can change. Check the company's website for its current services and locations.

Frequently asked

What is RevenueBase SmartSearch?

RevenueBase SmartSearch finds niche companies by the meaning of their business descriptions in the RevenueBase company graph. Exact, Similar, Related and Broad control how closely companies must fit your description. This list uses Exact for “reciprocal insurers”; each Exact match badge shows search membership, not an individual similarity or quality score.

How many reciprocal insurers are there based in the United States?

RevenueBase identified 206 company matches for reciprocal insurers associated with the United States as of November 2026, using the meaning of business descriptions at Exact. This is the recorded matched set in the RevenueBase company graph.

What is the largest company on this list?

Shelter Insurance Companies tops the displayed preview by professional contacts tracked in RevenueBase. Recorded headquarters appear in the company rows.

Which city has the most reciprocal insurers?

Raleigh leads with 4 company records, followed by Washington (4) and Boston (3).

How do I get contact information for these companies?

A free RevenueBase account lets you run this exact search and work limited free results with 500 credits to start. Upgrading provides access to the 9,216 professional contacts with verified work emails tracked across these 206 companies; direct dials are available where recorded.

How current is this list?

The list refreshes periodically as the company graph is re-checked. This page's figures were pulled on November 6, 2026.

Ready to reach these companies? Verified emails and direct dials for all 206 reciprocal insurers based in the United States. Start with a free account, no credit card.

Download this list →

Related lists

About this data

RevenueBase is a B2B data infrastructure company. Its company graph covers 60 million companies and 398.9 million professional contacts, with emails verified on a rolling cadence rather than scraped once and left to decay. These company lists are generated directly from that graph with RevenueBase SmartSearch, the same natural-language company search every RevenueBase user has: describe a market in plain words, get the companies that match, and add verified emails and direct dials for the people at them. It is the same data that powers RevenueBase's B2B data products, and a free account includes 500 credits to start. How these lists are built and judged.